Magic 5 Pie Co. Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to Magic 5 Pie Co., located in the heart of Norwalk, CT! Here, you’ll find a delightful fusion of flavorful Italian cuisine and artisanal pizzas, all crafted with fresh, local ingredients. The menu showcases unique specials like the Magic Fried Shrimp and the enchanting White Pie of the Week: Hawaii Pie, each crafted to tantalize your taste buds.
For lunch, you can design your own pizza masterpiece or savor their Hot Tub, brimming with flavors. Guests rave about the Lil Guy pizza and their refreshing salads, such as the Sicilian Margherita and Maneros Gorgonzola Salad, perfect for a casual meal or a special occasion.
The relaxed atmosphere, complete with a charming outdoor courtyard, makes Magic 5 Pie Co. a perfect gathering spot. With friendly staff and a well-curated drink menu, every visit promises a magical experience!
Calzones
Calzones
US$18.00
Soup Du Jour
US$8.00
Baked Burrata
US$18.00
Pork Belly Bites
US$11.00
Pork & Veal Meatballs
US$14.00
Spinach & Artichoke Dip
US$9.50
Gambas Al Ajillo
US$12.00
Tempura Scallops
US$17.50
Crocks, Cast Irons & Cazuelas
Eat Your Veggies
Brussels Sprouts
US$9.50
Parmesan Potatoes
US$9.00
Roasted Asparagus
US$9.50
House Marinated Olives
US$7.50
Bavarian Pretzel
US$8.50
Roasted Stuffed Jalapenos
US$11.50
Calamari Frites
US$19.00
Manero's Style Garlic Bread
US$9.50
Baked Clams
US$17.00
Chicken Satay
US$11.00
Honey Whipped Ricotta
US$12.00
Appetizers
Salads
Tuscan Kale
US$17.00
Roasted Cauliflower
US$19.00
Magic Artisan Salad
US$17.00
Stuffed Avocado
US$25.00
Belgian Caeser
US$17.00
Arugula Salad
US$17.00
Iceberg Wedge
US$17.00
Side House Salad
US$12.00
Cherry Bomb
US$21.00
Margherita
US$18.00
Lil Gal
US$21.00
Magic Five
US$20.00
Veggie Pie
US$21.00
Native Son
US$23.00
The Bruce
US$25.00
Potato Pie
US$22.00
Quattro Formaggio
US$21.00
Bianca
US$21.00
Diavola
US$20.00
Hot Oil Crunch
US$18.00
Salad
US$18.00
Mediterranean
US$20.00
Lil Guy
US$21.00
Fig Jam
US$21.00
Pastor
US$21.00
The JJ
US$23.00
BYOP Base Tomato & Mozzarella
US$15.00
BYOP Base Ricotta & Mozzarella
US$17.00
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
US$21.00
Pies
Sweet Magic
NY Style Cheesecake
US$11.00
Affogato
US$9.00
Tiramisu
US$11.00
"Orphans" & Ricotta
US$12.00
Side Of Tomato Sauce
US$2.50
Side Of Cheese
US$3.50
Side Of Avocado
US$2.50
Side Of Hot Oil
US$2.00
Side Of Truffle Oil
US$2.50
Side Of Truffle Honey
US$2.00
Side Of Hot Oil Crunch
US$3.50
Side Of Evoo
US$2.00
Side Of Blue Cheese Dressing
US$2.00
Side Of Lemon Honey Vinaigrette Dressing
US$2.00
Side Of Caesar Dressing
US$2.00
Side Of White Balsamic
US$2.00
Extra Pita Bread
US$2.50
Side Of Shredded Chicken
US$8.00
Side Of Magic Fries
US$8.50
Sides
Lunch Appetizers
Pork & Veal Meatballs Lunch
US$14.00
Manero’s Style Garlic Bread Lunch
US$9.50
Chicken Wings Lunch
US$13.50
French Fries Lunch
US$5.00
Onion Rings Lunch
US$6.00
Tuscan Kale Salad Lunch
US$13.50
Belgian Caesar Salad Lunch
US$13.50
Roasted Cauliflower Salad Lunch
US$13.50
Arugula Salad Lunch
US$13.50
Magic Artisan Salad Lunch
US$13.50
Iceberg Wedge Salad Lunch
US$13.50
Stuffed Avocado Salad Lunch
US$25.00
Side House Salad Lunch
US$12.00
Lunch Salads
Lunch Calzones & Strombolis
Calzone Lunch
US$18.00
Stromboli Lunch
US$21.50
Chicken Salad Wrap Lunch
US$12.50
Tuna Salad Wrap Lunch
US$12.50
Chicken Caesar Wrap Lunch
US$12.50
Buffalo Chicken Wrap Lunch
US$12.50
Chicken Souvlaki Wrap Lunch
US$12.50
Lunch Wraps
Lunch Grinders
Sausage, Pepper & Onion Grinder Lunch
US$14.00
Meatball Parm Grinder Lunch
US$14.00
Eggplant Parm Grinder Lunch
US$14.00
Chicken Parm Grinder Lunch
US$14.00
Italian Combo Grinder Lunch
US$14.00
Build Your Own Pizza Lunch
US$15.00
Lunch Pizza
Lunch Specialty Pizza
Cherry Bomb Pizza Lunch
US$21.00
Bianca Pizza Lunch
US$21.00
Margherita Pizza Lunch
US$18.00
Diavola Pizza Lunch
US$20.00
Lil Gal Pizza Lunch
US$21.00
Hot Oil Crunch Pizza Lunch
US$18.00
Magic Five Pizza Lunch
US$18.00
Salad Pizza Lunch
US$18.00
Veggie Pizza Lunch
US$21.00
Mediterranean Pizza Lunch
US$20.00
Native Son Pizza Lunch
US$23.00
Lil Guy Pizza Lunch
US$23.00
The Bruce Pizza Lunch
US$25.00
Fig Jam Pizza Lunch
US$21.00
Potato Pizza Lunch
US$22.00
Pastor Pizza Lunch
US$21.00
Quattro Formaggio Pizza Lunch
US$21.00
The JJ Pizza Lunch
US$23.00
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Lunch
US$21.00
Caprese Panini Lunch
US$15.00
Tuna Melt Panini Lunch
US$15.00
Shredded Chicken Panini Lunch
US$15.00
Prosciutto Panini Lunch
US$15.00
Veggie Panini Lunch
US$15.00
Cubano Panini Lunch
US$17.00
Lunch Paninis
Lunch The Bourdain
The Bourdain Sandwich Lunch
US$14.00
Magic Fried Shrimp Special
US$14.00
Magic Fried Calamari Special
US$16.00
Maneros Gorgonzola Salad Special
US$17.00
Red Pie Of The Week - Romesco Special
US$25.00
White Pie Of The Week- Hawaii Pie Special
US$24.00
Philly Cheese Steak Pie Special
US$26.00
Sicilian Margherita Pizza Special
US$28.00
Sicilian Garlic Stick Pie Special
US$27.00
Magic Donuts Special
US$15.00
Waffle "Nachos" Special
US$11.00
Triple Chocolate Magic Cake Special
US$11.00
Seafood Salad Special
US$21.00
Specials
Hot Tub
Hot Tub
US$13.00